A Response to “Giving Torture the Silent Treatment”

I agree with James that the evangelical community has been too quiet regarding the torture issue.  This is certainly an area where we should feel free to be critical of the current administration.  They have consistently weaseled around on the torture issue.  Even if they aren’t really authorizing terrible things, they certainly make it look like they must be.  I think this has had a huge negative impact on the way the rest of the world sees the United States, and has eroded our positive image in the world.  I can’t claim the same ignorance toward torture as James (after all I live on the California coast, where everyone seems certain that Bush is the antichrist), but I also can’t claim to have done, said, or even thought much about it. While the most compelling reasons for opposing torture are plain within scripture, I will expand on the notion that there are compelling pragmatic reasons to avoid torture.

Last fall I heard a fascinating interview on Fresh Air of a military interrogator and intelligence expert Col. Stuart Herrington, who currently teaches interrogation for the army.  He explains that a “professional” interrogator would never use brute force techniques such as torture.  This, he says, is simply not the way one gets information out of people.  It is interesting to see his take on what has been going on in military interrogations of the last few years (of which he led a classified review). The whole segment deals with portrayal of torture on TV and is also interesting.  The interview of Col. Herrington starts around minute 10, if you would like to hear just it.  I will also warn the sensitive reader that the first portion of the interview (before 10 minutes) contains a short audio segment of a torture scene from a TV show.

Finally, I want to address one of John’s comments to James’ post. John says this:

First of all, be careful of what and who you read. Just doing a little bit of ‘Googleing’ on the internet I found out that David Gushee is part of the ‘Baptist World Alliance’ group that the Southern Baptist Convention decided to not become a part of in 2004. See this article: http://www.bpnews.net/bpnews.asp?id=17748

I found it a little surprising that John says to “be careful of what and who we read.”  It seems to me much more important to think critically about whatever we read and judge it on its own merits, rather than only reading people with whom we think we will agree.  I doubt John really meant it in this way, but I thought it was worth clarifying.  Of course it also can be useful to know a writer’s background and motives (perhaps this is what John meant).  Regarding David Gushee I might mention that he is a Southern Baptist. Perhaps John is worried that Gushee’s theology is out of whack simply because other people associated with the Baptist World Alliance (BWA) have troubling views. However, the BWA has a wide variety of members (I think that’s the point).  If one wanted to get a good idea of why Gushee might feel led to take part in a group such as the BWA I would suggest reading this article (which actually doesn’t mention the BWA, but does help one to understand where Gushee is coming from).  Finally, I’ll mention that of all of the material I read for our Politics and Religion Series, Gushee’s book was the most carefully reasoned and scripturally sound viewpoint I saw.  John, I would encourage you to read his book.  Since you’ve thought a lot more about politics than James and I have, it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on it.

-Matt, the elder brother


2 Responses to A Response to “Giving Torture the Silent Treatment”

  1. John says:

    Matt, your right about what I wrote. I’m not the most clear writer. I read material from those I disagree with ALL the time. You of course are right in that we must be read everything with a critical eye. I am such a skeptic of most of everything I read.

    I do need to read David Gushee (when I have the time!) in order to develop a better opinion on him. This is what I was trying to say: I suppose I’ve developed a sort of political ‘sixth sense’ over the years-it’s hard to explain. The language you were using when you quoted Gushee got my antenna’s a-tingling.

    David Gushee didn’t sound like a Southern Baptist (and by that I mean of the Southern Baptist Convention). He sounds more to me like someone who is part of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship. This is the group of ‘moderates’ who seperated from the SBC in 1991 after the conservative/moderate power struggle in the Convention. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative_Baptist_Fellowship . I am mindful of ”judge not, lest you be judged.” I don’t doubt that he is a Christian and a Baptist, HOWEVER one joins a group because you believe in most of the tenants of that group. I’m a Republican (which are ‘fighting words’ where you live Matt!) because I believe in MOST of the values that Republicans hold. Not all of them, by any means. Mr. Gushee is part of the BWA for a reason . . .

    Well, I’m going to sign off now. I’m tired . . . and that probably is Bush’s fault (like everything else).

  2. NoPockets says:

    I, too, agree that Christians as a whole have been pretty silent concerning torture as a tactic for the military. I think that most Christians when they think about it would most likely be against torture, though probably not all. Maybe with a shift to a different administration (whatever party that may be) will address this issue and hopefully work towards restoring our nation’s reputation in the world. Critical thinking about what one reads (or hears) is a key to figuring out what seems right. Thanks again, Matt & James, for addressing an issue that I knew about but hadn’t ever really stopped to think about. As usual, you both bring up some things that show a deeper analysis of the situation which makes me want to do my homework better on issues like this so that I have made an active decision on where I stand.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: